Butchers Bone Broth Review: Do They Use Real Bones?

Butchers Bone Broth Reviews

Butcher's Bone Broth is marketed as one-of-a-kind broth with "special powers" because it has collagen and a weird package. But can you trust it? Or is it garbage.

You're a busy person and you just don't have the time to try out all of the different types of broths that are available. That is why you came here.

I'm going to break down what is good and bad about this product.

There are so many options out there that seem like they would taste delicious and be high quality, but they really aren't worth it.

In addition to reviewing its pros and cons, I'll also give some tips on where to find the best ones on the market for the lowest price.

My goal is to help you make an informed decision about whether or not this one is worth your money. Before we get started, I'll say that the overall best chicken bone broth I've seen is made by Bluebird Provisions.

It has way more protein with less salt. Ok let's get on to the review.

Roli roti bone broth products

Roli Roti Butchers Bone Broth - Who Are They?

Roli Roti Butchers Bone Broth is a popular brand of bone broth you can find in many stores across the USA. It is made with beef and chicken bones in order to create a delicious product that is packaged in a plastic bottle.

Roli Roti started as a single food truck in San Francisco. It now has a fleet of six and expanded into consumer packaged goods. They sell products ranging from sous vide chicken to pork carnitas and potatoes.

Doing more research, you can see that they are a large company now with products sold in Walmart, Albertsons, Kroger, HEB, Whole Foods, Safeway and more.

They were sold in some Costco locations but were discontinued.

Roli Roti Bone Broth Nutrition

Roli Roti bone broth nutrition facts are good. They include good amounts of protein with relatively low far and carbs. The nutrition makes these products keto and paleo friendly.

Roli Roti Chicken Bone Broth Nutrition Facts

Roli Roti chicken bone broth nutrition facts are great! They have a good amount of protein with 12 g per cup with zero carbs and zero fat. There is low sodium and some electrolytes as well with a solid ratio of salt to potassium.

Calories: 45

Fat: 0 g

Sodium: 110 mg

Carbohydrate: 0 g

Protein: 12 g

Potassium: 295 mg

Butchers chicken bone broth nutrition facts

Beef Bone Broth Nutrition Facts

The beef is similar to the chicken but with less protein and more fat. 2 g of fat is interesting when the chicken has zero. I would guess this is because they do not remove the fat in the beef, but do in the chicken. This is a bit confusing why they do not do the same for both.

Calories: 50

Fat: 2 g

Sodium: 90 mg

Carbohydrate: 0 g

Protein: 10 g

Potassium: 115 mg

Learn Which Bone Broth is Better for you: Beef or Chicken.

What are the key ingredients in Butchers bone broth?

The key ingredients in Butchers bone broth are water, chicken or beef and carrots. The ingredients are simmered in kettles then strained out and the broth is packaged.

Butcher's Chicken Ingredients

Water, Organic Chicken, and Organic Carrots.

Butcher's Beef Ingredient and Nutrient Breakdown

Water, Organic Beef And Organic Carrots.

Ingredient Analysis

The ingredient list in Roli Roti bone broth is straightforward with only 3 in each product. That being said, there are a few interesting things to note.

There is no mention of bones on either product package. Just 'beef' and 'chicken.' I've never seen this before in any other bone broth. They always have bones as the second ingredient (behind water).

Bones in a pot for broth

There are a few possible reasons for this.

  1. They are not using bones, but are using meat, skin and other parts of the animal instead.
  2. They simply left out the word 'bones.' This is strange given the name of the product.
  3. There is a compliance reason for this. For example: the USDA or FDA made them label it as such. Likely related to bullet point #1 above.

Looking for other options? Read my review of the 6 BEST bone broths this year.

What do customers say about Butcher's bone broth?

Butcher's bone broth is mainly sold in grocery stores across the USA. For this reason, it is difficult to find objective reviews and feedback on the taste and quality.

But don't worry, I can dig up customer feedback on anything... trust me.

Some customers enjoyed the high protein and good taste. But others said it tasted like 'salty water' and had lacked the rich flavor that other brands have.

Butchers Bone Broth Reviews

I put together a list of a few recent Butchers bone broth reviews for you to see. Check them out below.

This customer was not happy about the price deception and the flavor was bland and lacked some punch.

Butchers bone broth review

The customer review below found some inconsistencies in the product. They found a delicious, collagen rich version at costco before it got discontinued.

Then, when they found the product in another store, it was not the same. This one was 'watery.'

Roli Roti bone broth review

Overall, it seems as though Roli Roti is having quality and consistency issues with their products. Bone broth is incredibly difficult to make at a mass scale. Perhaps these are just growing pains as they expand across the USA.

How does Butcher's compare to other brands?

Butchers bone broth is a quality product, but bone broth is a highly competitive category, with lots of great options. Let's see how they compare to a popular up and coming brand called Bluebird Provisions.

Bluebird specializes in high protein dehydrated products that actually have the rich and delicious flavor or a fresh product.

These are shelf stable and convenient for travel. You don't have to worry about storing it in the fridge or freezer, or having it go bad since the shelf life is two years.

Chicken broth brands comparison chart

As you can see from the chart above, Bluebird has the same amount of protein, but at a fraction of the cost. The rest of the labels are similar in terms of nutrition, electrolytes, vitamins and minerals.


The cost of Roli Roti is $7.46 per bottle, and you get three servings. So this works out to $2.49 per serving. On the other hand, Bluebird works out to $1.78 per serving, a bit more cost effective.

Sourcing and Ingredients

Roli Roti does not mention where they source their materials from. And we can't confirm whether they use bones, since it is not listed on package.

Below you'll see the ingredients for both. You can see that Bluebird uses one simple ingredient. They use pasture raised and grass fed animals. There is no mention where the animals from Roli Roti are sourced from an what conditions they live under.

Roli Roti bone broth ingredients

What About Eco Friendly Packaging?

Bluebird Provisions uses a 100% recyclable standup zip pouch. Making it the more eco friendly option for those who care about the environment.

On the other hand, Roli Roti is packaged in a single use plastic bottle.

Is Butchers Bone Broth Safe?

Butchers bone broth is safe provided that you pay attention to the expiry date and storage instructions. You must keep in refrigerated and use wit within 7 days of opening. If you fail to follow these instructions, you risk your own health and safety by drinking it.

Closing Thoughts

If you’re looking for an option that you can find in grocery stores, Butcher’s bone broth is an option. That being said, there are some issues with the product.

For this reason, there are other options that have more protein, less salt at a lower price. If you’re looking for the most nutrient-dense bone broth possible, you may want to check out Bluebird Provisions, who are available on Amazon Prime.

Have you tried this brand? Do you like it? Or is there another brand you want me to review? Leave a comment and I will get back to you asap.

Leave a comment

All comments are moderated before being published


Great taste and texture. Will be purchasing this again. Works great on its own for sipping and also in soup!"

Adrienne L