Bone Broth Amazon Comparison Chart
You are looking for the best bone broth on Amazon, but there are so many options and you don’t know where to start.
With so many options available, it can be hard to know which one is the right fit for you.
I've compiled a chart of 18+ of the best bone broth products on Amazon, from Ancient Nutrition, Bare Bones, Kettle and Fire to Dr. Kellyann and more.
This chart compares all of the top brands head to head by their protein, ingredients (including nasty fillers), quality, cost, sodium and more.
You might be surprised that a small brand like Bluebird Provisions occupies the top spot. Read the chart to see why.
What are the different types of bone broth on Amazon?
The different types of bone broth on Amazon are liquid products, powders and bone broth protein. Let's go through each briefly to avoid any confusion.
Liquid bone broth is well... in a liquid state. It is the most common form you see in products today. They are typically packaged in standup pouches, tetra-pak cartons or glass jars.
Powder bone broth is liquid that is dehydrated. It generally shares the same nutritional benefits as liquid. In some cases, it has more protein and collagen than other types. These are usually packaged in plastic tubs or jars and standup zip pouches.
Bone broth protein is a powder that has isolated only the protein and stripped the natural, beef or chicken flavor out of the product. Then artificial flavors or those dreaded 'natural flavors' (nothing natural about them) are added to make it taste like chocolate, vanilla or something else.
Here is a sneak peek at all the details you get in this free chart.
How to Choose a Bone Broth on Amazon
The nutrition facts, reviews and ingredient panel are the only objective sources of information you have to judge whether a bone broth on Amazon is a good fit for your goals... or if it's better off in the garbage.
So what exactly are we looking for?
- At least 10 g protein per serving. Anything less is simply a mislabelled broth and not a real bone broth. You will get none of the glorious health benefits without this much protein.
- Less than 180 mg sodium per serving. We get way too much salt in our standard diets. If you plan on drinking it multiple times per week, the sodium adds up quickly.
- No yeast extract, natural flavors or fillers. These junk, filler ingredients are awful for your digestion and gut health. They are used to hide a bad tasting product because of their addictive qualities and ability to simulate meat tastes at a low cost.
- No artificial sweeteners (stevia, monkfruit, etc). Similar to what I mentioned above. Even the new ones that are supposed to be 'healthy,' we don't know the long-term effects. Many of them wreak havoc on your digestive system and mess with your gut health.
Before this, there was no honest way to compare amazon bone broth powders.
Food companies and supplement brands spend piles of money to convince you their products are good for you.
However, many bone broths are still high in ultra-processed ingredients and have mysterious “flavors”, fillers, salt bombs and gums that can disrupt your gut.
Best Bone Broths on Amazon
The best bone broths on Amazon include Bluebird Provisions, Kettle and Fire, Vital Proteins, Bare Bones and more. Read the full list in my bone broth comparison chart linked above and below. This way you can compare them head to head in one convenient chart.
Bluebird Provisions Chicken Bone Broth Powder
The simplest option with the most protein and best reviews. 12 g protein, no carbs, no fat and only 160 mg sodium. A great choice for you to try today.
Kettle & Fire
Kettle & Fire bone broth is included as one of the best on Amazon because of its high quality and because they are one of the biggest brands out there. They have tons of soups and other flavors as well. One of the better liquid options you will find.
Ancient Nutrition Bone Broth Protein Powder
Ancient Nutrition Bone Broth Protein Powder is included as as popular bone broth on Amazon because it has a wide variety of reviews. But when you dig into the specifics, there are some issues. Check a sample of the chart below to see what I mean. You'll need to check the whole chart to understand it fully.
Dr Kellyann has taken the internet by storm with her book, weight loss programs and massive product line. This product has collagen, natural flavors and a variety of vegetable powders and extracts so spice up the flavor.
Jarrow Formulas Beyond
More of a joint care supplement than a bone broth, Jarrow Formulas combines collagen, chondroitin and a bit of chicken bone broth down on the ingredients list. It is so low that it really begs why they label it as such.
You'll also find dextrin, maltodextrin and natural flavors in this product. If you you have a sensitive stomach, then this may cause some issues.
OM Mushroom is primarily a functional mushroom powder brand. However, they've dipped into bone broth by adding it to their mushroom extracts. The products have decent reviews and seem to have some quality, Organic ingredients.
LonoLife Bone Broth Packets
Lonolife bone broth packets are powder products that are packaged in single serve sachets. The funny thing is that the beef one has no bone broth listed in the ingredients. It has collagen and 'beef.' Seems as though it is mislabelled. Get the full scoop in the comparison chart.
Bare Bones Broth Packets
Bare Bones Broth packets are shelf stable powder products with a lot of added filler ingredients like yeast extract, natural flavors, maltodextrin, guar gum, chicory root fiber and collagen.
Left Coast Performance Beef Bone Broth
Left Coast Performance Beef Bone Broth is one of the most popular ones on Amazon because it is high in protein and has been around for longer than most. Left Coast was recently sold to a private equity / investment firm. So it is difficult to say if anything has changed in their operations.
NOW Sports Nutrition
A popular sports nutrition brand, NOW Sports released this bone broth protein. It is not all that popular but does show up in many searches.
So there you have it, 15+ of the best bone broths on Amazon, in one easy-to-compare chart. If you’re looking to try bone broth for the first time, I recommend a convenient and delicious tasting chicken bone broth powder like the one from Bluebird Provisions.
Their product has more protein and collagen per gram than any other on the list. It's sourced from non-GMO, pasture-raised bones and is slow-simmered for 24 hours to extract the maximum amount of nutrients. Plus, it’s shelf-stable, so you can keep it in your pantry for when you need it.
There is really no difference between liquid and powder, provided that the company is sourcing things correctly, using quality ingredients and making it using a traditional low and slow simmer.
Is the “Good” bone broth better for you than the “Good” bone broth powder?